Refine Search
Sort by
$479,900
4 Beds 3 Baths 7079212 MLS 2,021 SqFt.
Beautifully refreshed and move-in ready in The Willows, one of Gilbert's most inviting communities! This stylish home has been thoughtfully updated with fresh interior paint, new carpet, luxury vinyl plank flooring, modern light fixtures, updated ceiling fans, new faucets, and more. The versatile floor plan features a desirable downstairs bedroom and full bath--perfect for guests, a home office, or multi-generational living. The kitchen has been refreshed with quartz countertops, recently painted cabinetry, and a clean, modern look that feels bright and inviting. A two-car garage and thoughtful finishes throughout complete the home. Step outside and enjoy everything The Willows has to offer, including two community pools, basketball and volleyball courts, a children's playground and more! expansive greenbelts, and beautiful outdoor spaces. Ideally located near Gilbert's popular shopping, dining, entertainment, and everyday conveniences. Freshly updated, beautifully presented, and ready to impress!

4346 E Carla Vista Drive, Gilbert

$421,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 7079006 MLS 1,401 SqFt.
Fall in love with this charming corner-lot residence tucked into a cul-de-sac in the Cottonwoods Crossing Community! Featuring 3 beds, 2 baths, a manicured front yard, and a 2-car garage. Inside, you'll find vaulted ceilings, abundant natural light, wood-look floors t/out, and an excellent open floor plan creating a fresh & airy feel. The eat-in kitchen boasts plenty of wood cabinetry, a pantry, SS appliances, and a bay window that brings in extra natural light. A versatile bonus room can be used as a home office or dining area. The perfectly sized main bedroom includes a private bath for added convenience. Outside, the backyard is complete with a covered patio and generous grassy area, ideal for relaxing or entertaining. Great location with easy access to US-60 & Loop 202. Move-in ready!

938 S San Joaquin Court, Gilbert

$449,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 7078880 MLS 1,696 SqFt.
Welcome home to Breckenridge Manor, one of Gilbert's gems! This home features no neighbors to the front, and backs to a community road, offering lots of privacy. As you enter the home, you will notice the formal living or potential office with a double-sided fireplace. The family room has a dining area and is just off your large kitchen. The vaulted ceilings offer expansive space and lots of room. Some great upgrades include dual pane windows, chef's kitchen, paint and lots of tile flooring, and no carpet. This home is one of the few homes that features a private front yard courtyard. Close to highly performing Gilbert Schools, lots of restaurants and job centers. Downtown Gilbert is just around the corner for all your fun outings. Close to the canal trail system and Gilbert Recreation Center. Lots to do so close to home!

709 N Larkspur Street, Gilbert

$415,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 7078809 MLS 1,153 SqFt.
Resort style living in the active 55+ adult community of Trilogy at Power Ranch. This 2-bedroom home has been recently upgraded in the past few months. You will notice it is freshly painted, has new carpet in the bedrooms, all new stainless appliances in the light and bright kitchen, wood like flooring in the great room and dining area, and tile in other areas. This Cassia model is 1153 square feet with a split floor plan, open living area with high ceilings, and a bay window. The master has a walk-in closet, its own bath with shower and double sinks. Located in the opposite area of the home is the guest bedroom and bath giving guests or family their own space to enjoy. The two-car garage with cabinets has been freshly painted, and the AC is two years old. Come enjoy all this community has to offer with amenities you will enjoy such as golf, tennis, pickleball, pools, workout facility, bocce, many clubs and a restaurant.

4636 E Walnut Road, Gilbert

$499,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 7078650 MLS 2,676 SqFt.
This beautiful 4-bedroom, 3-bath Gilbert home offers an impressive 2,676 square feet of comfortable, well-designed living space, making it an ideal home for a growing family! The inviting floor plan features spacious living and dining areas, a cozy loft, and a versatile den, providing plenty of room for everyone to spread out. Numerous recent updates add comfort, style, and energy efficiency, including new energy-efficient Lennox 19.5 SEER A/C units, new exterior paint, a newer water heater, water softener, updated fixtures, and dual-pane windows. The downstairs features easy-care tile flooring, while the upstairs bathrooms feature luxury plank flooring, and every toilet in the home is equipped with a bidet for added convenience. The gorgeous kitchen is the heart of the home, featuring ample cabinet and counter space, charming farmhouse-style shelving, and a beautiful center island perfect for everyday meals and entertaining. The spacious primary suite offers plenty of room for a large bedroom and sitting area, while the en-suite bath features dual sinks, a separate tub and shower, and a generous walk-in closet. The large laundry room provides additional storage space and includes a newer washer and dryer. Step outside to the expansive backyard with a covered patio, creating the perfect space to relax, entertain, or enjoy a peaceful Arizona afternoon. Low-maintenance desert landscaping makes outdoor upkeep a breeze, while the community pool and heated community spa provide additional opportunities to relax and enjoy the Arizona lifestyle. A 2-car garage with built-in cabinets offers excellent storage and functionality. Ideally located in a desirable Gilbert area close to excellent schools, fine dining, shopping, and everyday conveniences, this beautifully updated home offers the space, comfort, and amenities a growing family has been looking for!

4532 E Oxford Lane, Gilbert

$445,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 7078645 MLS 1,632 SqFt.
Welcome to 889 E Stottler Dr, a well-designed 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home in a convenient Gilbert location. The main level features an open and inviting floor plan with wood-look flooring, plenty of natural light, and an easy flow between the living, dining, and kitchen areas. The kitchen offers white cabinetry, granite countertops, stainless-steel appliances, a breakfast bar, and ample counter and storage space, making it equally practical for everyday living and entertaining. Upstairs, the spacious primary suite includes a large walk-in closet and private bath, while two additional bedrooms provide flexibility for family, guests, or a home office. A built-in workstation upstairs creates a dedicated space for working or studying without sacrificing a bedroom. Additional features include upstairs laundry, ceiling fans throughout, a two-car garage, and a low-maintenance backyard with a covered patio--perfect for enjoying the outdoors without spending your weekends on yardwork. Located near Lindsay and Warner, the home offers convenient access to shopping, dining, entertainment, Downtown Gilbert, and the SanTan Village area while still providing a comfortable residential setting. Clean, functional, and move-in ready, this Gilbert home offers a lot to appreciate inside and out.

889 E Stottler Drive, Gilbert

$499,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 7078210 MLS 1,702 SqFt.
Stunning Summer Meadows 3 BR 2 BA home in the heart of Gilbert. From the moment you walk in you will love the stunning windows and hard wood floors throughout the living room, great room, and bedrooms. Entertainers dream kitchen with ample cabinet space and beautiful granite counter tops. French doors lead to the stunning backyard with covered patio and grass area perfect for sitting out and enjoying time with the family. Primary bedroom with walk in closet and remodeled primary bath with quartz counter tops, double sinks and separate tub and shower. Two more bedrooms and an upgraded hall bath with quartz countertops plus inside laundry room complete this wing. New Roof 2020, new AC 2022, RV gate. Fantastic location close to downtown Gilbert, shopping and restaurants! A true value!

247 N Port Drive, Gilbert

$450,000
2 Beds 3 Baths 7078188 MLS 1,549 SqFt.
Beautiful townhome nestled in the heart of the vibrant Gilbert lifestyle. Offering 2 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms and an open and spacious floor plan. This home is filled with natural light and is thoughtfully laid out. The kitchen is the showstopper, with ample storage space, dual islands, a RO system and a seamless flow into the main living area. With a freshly painted interior, new flooring and no carpet throughout, it has a clean and new feel. The top floor features both the primary and guest suites. The primary suite includes a large walk-in closet and private en-suite bath with dual sinks. This gated community has fantastic amenities to enjoy- pools, parks, walking paths and lush landscaping. Ideally located minutes from SanTan Village, Costco, Sprouts and an abundance of

1671 E Dogwood Lane, Gilbert

$495,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 7078074 MLS 1,868 SqFt.
Welcome to this beautiful updated 3 bdrm, 2 bath home in the desirable San Tan Ranch community. Featuring a 3 car garage & inviting living spaces, this home is designed for both comfort & entertaining. The updated kitchen offers granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, a large breakfast bar, & eat-in dinging area, all opening to a spacious great room. A separate living room provides additional space for relaxing or entertaining. The primary suite features a walk-in closet & an updated bathroom w/dual vanities & a separate tub & shower. Both bathrooms have been tastefully updated. Enjoy Arizona evenings in the low maintenance backyard, complete w/a covered patio, pavers, grassy area, & built-in fire pit. A move-in ready home in a great Gilbert location. Come see all it has to offer.

3681 S Buckaroo Trail, Gilbert

$459,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 7078058 MLS 1,358 SqFt.
Sophisticated, stylish, and completely refreshed, this beautifully updated Gilbert home offers a polished take on modern East Valley living. Thoughtful upgrades include new luxury vinyl plank flooring, plush new carpet, freshly painted cabinetry, designer-inspired lighting and fixtures, and fresh interior and exterior paint. Vaulted ceilings and abundant natural light create an airy, upscale feel, while the kitchen showcases quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, a center island, and crisp updated cabinetry. The spacious primary suite offers a dual vanity and generous closet space, while the refreshed backyard provides a clean, low-maintenance setting for relaxing or entertaining. Ideally positioned near Chandler, Mesa, Tempe, Scottsdale, and Phoenix, this turnkey home delivers elevated style, comfort, and convenience in one exceptional package.

1239 W Breckenridge Avenue, Gilbert

$450,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 7077169 MLS 1,705 SqFt.
Welcome to this bright and inviting 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home, ideally situated on a desirable corner lot with a thoughtfully designed open floor plan. Fresh paint is being completed throughout the interior and exterior, giving the home a crisp, refreshed feel from the moment you arrive. The main living areas feature easy-care tile flooring, while carpeted bedrooms provide a comfortable contrast. A large sliding glass door creates a seamless connection between the interior and backyard, bringing in plenty of natural light and opening the home to the outdoor living space. The kitchen offers granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and beautifully detailed cabinetry with crown molding, creating a stylish and functional gathering space. The stainless appliances are approximately 2½ years old. Outside, the low-maintenance corner-lot landscaping includes a rock-covered front yard with established landscaping, while the backyard features artificial turf, planter boxes, and paver accents for an easy-care setting perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Major improvements include a new roof installed in February, with fresh exterior paint currently underway. The A/C is original, offering the opportunity for a future upgrade while the home already benefits from several recent improvements. With its open layout, desirable corner location, refreshed interiors, new roof, and low-maintenance backyard, this home offers a wonderful combination of comfort and value.

3480 S Jacana Lane, Gilbert

$455,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 7076914 MLS 2,187 SqFt.
A Fresh New Look in Cooley Station -Beautifully updated and professionally staged, this spacious 3-bedroom,3-bath townhome offers 2,187 sq. ft. of comfortable, flexible living space designed to adapt to the way you live. Fresh interior and exterior paint, new luxury vinyl plank flooring, and a light, refreshed feel throughout make this home truly move-in ready.One of the home's standout features is the additional flex room, offering valuable extra space for a home office, media room, fitness area, game room, creative space, or second living area-the possibilities can easily change along with your needs.At the heart of the home is an open and inviting kitchen featuring stainless steel appliances, abundant cabinetry, a walk-in pantry, and breakfast bar. Spacious living..see more and dining areas provide plenty of room to gather, entertain, unwind, or create multiple spaces that work for your lifestyle. All three bedrooms are privately situated together, including a generous primary suite that feels like its own retreat, complete with a walk-in closet, dual vanities, separate soaking tub and shower, and private water closet.A rare side-by-side two-car garage, water softener, and overhead garage storage add everyday convenience and functionality. Even better, the community pool is located directly across from the home, making it easy to enjoy Arizona's beautiful weather just steps from your front door. Located in desirable Cooley Station, you'll enjoy charming tree-lined streets, parks and community amenities, with shopping, dining, entertainment, and everyday conveniences just minutes away. More than move-in ready, this is a home with the space and flexibility to make it your own. Welcome Home!

905 S Osborn Lane, Gilbert

$449,900
3 Beds 3 Baths 7076759 MLS 1,753 SqFt.
Professional pictures coming soon! Discover gated living in the sought-after Enclave at Val Vista Lakes! This inviting 3-bedroom plus loft home features a spacious downstairs primary suite with a claw-foot tub and oversized walk-in shower. Upstairs, you will find a versatile loft with access to a private balcony and two additional bedrooms, with a newly remodeled bath and walk in shower. Highlights include new kitchen cabinetry with butcher-block counters, all new appliances, a wood-burning fireplace in the family room, and an updated AC unit. Enjoy exceptional Val Vista Lakes amenities, including a tropical lagoon, swimming pools, lakes, fitness center, tennis and pickleball courts, and miles of biking and walking paths. For homes in The Enclave, the secondary HOA maintains the front-yard landscaping.

1717 E Watercress Lane, Gilbert

$480,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 7076753 MLS 2,129 SqFt.
Super cute 3 bed 2 bath detached single family home in the Bungalows at Cooley Station! Upon entry you will find attractive tile, granite countertops, a gas stove, maple-colored cabinetry, oversized island, and a separate wet bar. Upstairs you'll find 3 unique and colorful rooms, with custom paint throughout. The primary is spacious and the attached bath has dual sinks and brushed nickel shower enclosure. There is built-in shelving in the loft, as well as 2 more colorful and fun bedrooms, a guest bathroom, and laundry room. All appliances, including fridge, washer, and dryer, convey with the house. The 2 car garage has polycuramine coating as well as a whole house water filtration and softening system. Outside your oversized sliding glass doors you have a covered patio and a side yard. Located right in front of a children's playground, the community also has lots of green spaces, a splash pad, and community pool. It's a welcoming and friendly area and within walking distance to a 9/10 (on Greatschools) rated Higley Traditional Academy.

3801 E Robert Street, Gilbert

$410,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 7076283 MLS 1,357 SqFt.
Location, charm, and convenience come together seamlessly in this Gilbert home! Ideally situated just minutes from the Loop 202 and surrounded by some of the East Valley's best shopping, dining, entertainment, and amenities, this location truly puts you close to everything. Enjoy easy access to Epicenter at Agritopia, Phoenix-Mesa Gateway Airport, SanTan Village, Revel Surf Park, Mercy Gilbert Medical Center, and countless restaurants and entertainment options, all within approximately 10 minutes of home. This charming single level home offers an open concept greatroom floorplan with 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and plenty of storage space, creating a comfortable and functional space for everyday living. Fresh interior and exterior paint give the home a clean, updated feel, while beautiful wood-look tile flooring flows throughout the entire home for a cohesive look and easy maintenance. The kitchen includes plenty of cabinet and countertop space, complete with a functional kitchen island and pantry. Step outside to a backyard designed for relaxing and entertaining! Enjoy a pavered patio, built-in BBQ, and built-in firepit with seating, making it perfect for gathering with family and friends on Arizona evenings. There is also plenty of room to add a lush grass area for kids, pets, or simply creating your own private outdoor retreat. You know what they say in real estate... it's all about Location, Location, Location, and this is an opportunity you won't want to miss!

3742 E Jasper Drive, Gilbert

$449,500
3 Beds 3 Baths 7075586 MLS 2,303 SqFt.
This spacious 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home with a 2-car garage offers a functional loft and huge living areas with plenty of room to spread out. Located near Recker and Warner with convenient access to the Loop 202, shopping, dining, and more. The kitchen features granite countertops, white cabinetry, a large island, double wall ovens, and a newer dishwasher. The oversized formal dining area offers plenty of flexibility and could easily be used as an additional living or entertaining space. Upstairs, the functional loft is perfect for a home office, game room, or second living area. The massive primary suite has plenty of room for a sitting area and features a large walk-in closet, dual sinks, separate tub and shower, and private toilet room. Secondary bedrooms share a convenient Jack-and-Jill bathroom. Enjoy the community pool and spa, large grassy park, and playground. Great location, spacious floor plan, and excellent value make this one a must-see!

4066 E Cathy Drive, Gilbert

$479,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 7075389 MLS 1,921 SqFt.
Beautiful Corner-Unit Townhome in Prime Gilbert Location! Enjoy resort-style community amenities including, gated community, three community pools and spas, lakes with waling paths. Conveniently located near SanTan Village, shopping, entertainment, dining including North Italia, Flower Child, and The Backyard. This spacious and well-appointed home offers the added privacy of only one shared wall, a 2-car garage, abundant natural light, a warm neutral color palette, and modern finishes throughout. The main level features tile flooring throughout and a beautifully designed kitchen with white cabinetry, crown molding, granite countertops, pendant lighting, stainless steel appliances, and a spacious walk-in pantry. A convenient half bath completes the downstairs living area. Upstairs, the generous primary suite features a large walk-in closet and ensuite bath with dual sinks and a glass-enclosed shower. The loft has been thoughtfully converted into a private office or flex space with French doors. A great opportunity to enjoy the comfort and convenience of Gilbert living in a desirable location.

1825 E Hampton Lane Unit 111, Gilbert

$475,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 7074916 MLS 1,300 SqFt.
One owner, and it shows. This 3-bedroom, 2-bath comes mostly furnished -- tile throughout, tasteful updates, and nothing left on your to-do list. Owned solar and a newer AC keep the electric bill averaging around $40 a month, which is a number worth reading twice. Out back, a sparkling pool and low-maintenance landscaping mean more evenings enjoying the yard and fewer weekends working on it. Downtown Gilbert dining, shopping, and entertainment sit about a mile away, freeway access is quick, and the walking paths around this lake community & the Western Canal Trail are close by when you'd rather walk or ride than drive. It has been maintained the way you would hope a one-owner home would be. Move-in ready in the truest sense -- bring a suitcase and call it done!

173 W Smoke Tree Road, Gilbert

$455,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 7074914 MLS 1,701 SqFt.
Modern newly built 3-bedroom, 3-bath townhome in Gilbert, Arizona, located in the gated Mosaic at Layton Lakes community. This upgraded two-story home features an open-concept great room, spacious kitchen with granite countertops, ample cabinetry and generous prep space, tile flooring throughout the main living areas, comfortable carpeted bedrooms and a private balcony. The attached two-car garage provides parking and storage. Mosaic at Layton Lakes features just 87 townhomes with resort-style amenities including a community pool and spa, clubhouse, playground, BBQ grills and walking paths. Enjoy low-maintenance living within the desirable Layton Lakes master-planned community near Gilbert shopping, dining, parks, recreation and major roadways.

746 E Doral Avenue Unit Unit 201, Gilbert

$490,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 7073456 MLS 1,479 SqFt.
Don't miss the opportunity to own this beautifully maintained Gilbert home, ideally located just minutes from Downtown Gilbert! This charming 3 BR, 2 BA home has been thoughtfully renovated w/ stylish finishes throughout, including granite countertops, LVP flooring, & an oversized primary bathroom shower. Step outside & enjoy your own private backyard retreat, perfect for entertaining or relaxing. The extended patio provides plenty of space for gatherings, while the large turf area & sparkling above-ground pool create the perfect setting for enjoying Arizona's beautiful weather. Nestled in a quiet & peaceful neighborhood, this home offers the perfect blend of comfort, style, & convenience. With thoughtful updates, inviting outdoor spaces, & a prime Gilbert location, this one is a must see

1144 S Nielson Street, Gilbert

$439,500
3 Beds 2 Baths 7073450 MLS 1,401 SqFt.
Presenting this inviting single-story Gilbert home in Cottonwoods Crossing, featuring a new roof (2024), HVAC system just 1 year old, and a neutral palette, ready for its next owner to make it their own. The functional split-bedroom floor plan offers 3 bedrooms and 2 baths, with vaulted ceilings enhancing the spacious great room. The eat-in kitchen features a breakfast bar, pantry, wood cabinetry, tile counters, and built-in appliances. The private primary suite includes an en-suite bath and walk-in closet. Step outside to a spacious backyard with a covered patio and fire pit--an inviting setting for relaxing, entertaining, or creating an outdoor space all your own. Additional features include north/south exposure, sun screens on all windows, no interior steps, an attached 2-car garage, and an extra-wide driveway offering additional parking space. For the golfer, Greenfield Lakes Golf Course is just across the street, adding another recreational option right nearby. Enjoy convenient access to Crossroads District Park, SanTan Village, Downtown Gilbert's Heritage District, shopping, dining, entertainment, recreation, and major commuter routes. Whether you're drawn to the Gilbert Unified School District, Gilbert's restaurants and entertainment, nearby recreation, or simply a cozy place to call your own, this home is ready for its next owner to enjoy all that Gilbert has to offer.

2339 E San Tan Drive, Gilbert

$449,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 7073303 MLS 1,284 SqFt.
AZ RESORT STYLE LIVING AT IT'S BEST! 3 bedroom,2 bath home w/new interior &exterior paint.New luxury vinyl flooring. Newly updated kitchen w/custom painted cabinetry, new stainless appliances, flattop stove,Quartz Countertops w/undermount stainless sink/faucet,new light fixture in dining area. New ceiling fans in Greatroom &primary bedroom.Newly updated guestbath with remodeled shower, custom painted cabinetry,new fixtures. Large Primary Bedroom w/en-suite bath and walk-in closet. Living area opens to desert landscape backyard, professionally done in August 2026. Greatroom opens to custom covered patio with built-in planters. Great entertaining layout. New HVAC System, Smart Thermostat. North/South exposure. Located in popular Seville Community, close to everything Gilbert has to offer

3366 E Packard Drive, Gilbert

$449,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 7073053 MLS 1,377 SqFt.
Perfect blend of location, price and potential in Gilbert! This 3 bed 2 bath home has a functional, well laid out floor plan nestled within Cooper Ranch. With versatile living spaces and vaulted ceilings, plenty of natural light floods throughout. The kitchen features a gas range with ample counter and cabinet space. There is plenty of room for an island! Plantation shutters add character, and recessed lighting and ceiling fans are found throughout. Step outside to your private backyard with a PebbleTec pool, extended covered patio, dog run and low maintenance landscaping. Mature, lush trees beyond the rear yard provide a green backdrop and added privacy without the upkeep. OWNED Solar! North/south exposure is another Arizona bonus! With solid bones and plenty of opportunity to customize over time, this home is a great option for a first-time buyer, investor or anyone looking to make a home their own. A hard to find combination in Gilbert!

981 W Hudson Way, Gilbert

$425,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 7072200 MLS 1,281 SqFt.
Set in Gilbert's Western Skies golf course community, this inviting home offers easy living with desert landscaping and artificial turf, plus a 2024 A/C and water heater. Inside, vaulted ceilings and an open floorplan fill the home with natural light across tile flooring. The spacious great room flows into the breakfast nook and kitchen, featuring stainless steel appliances, island and breakfast bar. The laundry room is conveniently located off the kitchen. The generous primary suite opens to the patio and features an en suite bath with dual sinks, barn door, upgraded walk-in shower and walk-in closet. Enjoy an extended covered patio and view fencing overlooking the golf course & a built-in BBQ!

1531 E Black Diamond Drive, Gilbert

$409,999
3 Beds 3 Baths 7071982 MLS 1,336 SqFt.
Tucked into Gateway Court, this Gilbert home sits in a safe, quiet neighborhood with very little street traffic in front of the house. Inside, the functional floorplan makes good use of the space, with beautiful flooring throughout, a fireplace, and vaulted ceilings that give the main living areas an open feel. The kitchen has custom cabinets, stainless steel appliances, brand new dishwasher, and new countertops and backsplash completed in 2025. Downtown Gilbert is just 1.7 miles away, close enough to walk or bike to the restaurants, shops, and everything else that makes the area so popular. The community also has a pool for residents to enjoy. If you want the convenience of being close to downtown without giving up a quieter place to come home to, this one is worth seeing.

31 W Hancock Avenue, Gilbert

Copyright 2026 Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service, All rights reserved. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) nor Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless.